Why Bullet Loans Were the Silver Bullet
By Nitin Misra (Co-Founder, indiagold) · 2026-11-18 · 7 min read
At indiagold we run no bullet schemes. Every customer pays interest on a schedule. That can look like a commercial disadvantage when competitors offer loans with nothing to pay for twelve months. The September-quarter results of the large gold lenders show what the bullet structure leaves unmeasured.
Why did bullet become the default?
It suited the borrower, the branch and the lender.
The borrower pays nothing until the end, which fits income that arrives in lumps/seasonal. The branch runs no monthly collection. For the lender, the rate rises the longer interest goes unpaid. In HDFC Securities' illustration of a six-month bullet loan, the annual rate is 22% when interest is paid within 30 days and 30% once it has gone unpaid for more than 180 days, while the rebate falls from 8% to zero.
Many of these loans close early. HDFC Securities puts the behavioural tenure at gold loan NBFCs such as Muthoot and Manappuram at four to six months. Crisil found in June 2026 that about 90% of twelve-month bullet loans are repaid by the end of tenure, mainly through pre-closure.
Two large lenders have put numbers on it. Manappuram's chief financial officer told analysts on the September-quarter results call that bullet loans are more than 90% of its gold book. Bajaj Finance said on its call that 99% of its gold loan customers are on bullet repayment.
Who leaned on it most?
I have not found a published split of gold loans by repayment structure. The TransUnion CIBIL and CRIF reports break the market down by lender, ticket size and delinquency, and neither separates bullet from EMI. So the evidence is indirect.
Banks hold the larger book. ICRA puts banks at about 78% of organised gold loans in March 2026 and says two-thirds of the bank book is non-retail lending, for agriculture and other uses. Bank agricultural gold loans commonly allow a single repayment within twelve months. Indian Overseas Bank's Swarna Agri loan is repaid in one payment of principal and interest. Canara Bank's crop loan can be repaid in instalments or as a lump sum.
NBFC gold loans cost the borrower more. HDFC Securities puts NBFC yields at 17 to 20%, against bank retail gold loan rates of 9 to 11%. Experian's June 2026 report links the shift in new lending towards private banks and NBFCs to wider reach and faster turnaround.
Private banks wrote 13.8% of new gold loans by value in the June 2026 quarter, on CRIF's numbers. I found no public data on their product mix, so I have left them out.
What kept it safe?
In my reading, a rising gold price did. Most of the growth in gold loans came from price and little from new gold.
TransUnion CIBIL counts gold loan balances up 3.8 times between March 2022 and December 2025, and CRIF puts the book at Rs 18.6 lakh crore in March 2026. ICRA says NBFC gold loan growth over the past five years was driven largely by gold prices, with the gold held as collateral rising at a modest pace. At Muthoot, gold loan assets grew 43% in the year to September 2026 while the gold it holds fell from 209 to 204 tonnes. The Reserve Bank's June 2026 Financial Stability Report says the recent growth came mainly from existing borrowers using higher gold prices to take larger loans and roll over existing debt.
What did it hide?
Three things are not visible in a bullet book.
The real loan-to-value. HDFC Securities works an example of a Rs 1 lakh bullet loan at 22% interest, disbursed at 60% of the gold's value. Counting interest, it stands at 67% after six months and 74% after twelve. If gold then falls 20%, the loan is at 79% when it is three months old and 93% when it is twelve months old.
Repayment behaviour. A bullet loan cannot be overdue before maturity. Manappuram says 60 to 65% of its customers pay interest promptly without any schedule. For the remaining 35 to 40%, a bullet loan produces no repayment data until it is closed or matures.
Who is borrowing. TransUnion CIBIL studied 171 million gold loan accounts opened in 2024. In 14% of them the borrower had been more than 90 days overdue on a loan in the three months before, and in 23% more than 30 days overdue. Piramal Finance's chief executive estimated on an October results call that 15 to 23% of FY26 gold loan disbursements went to borrowers more than 90 days overdue on another loan. A bullet loan to such a borrower shows no repayment record until it is closed or matures.
There is a precedent. Analysts found in 2013 that Manappuram's loan-to-value on loans disbursed between August 2011 and January 2012 was close to 85%, counted on principal alone. Gold corrected about 20% in 2013. HDFC Securities notes that the same period brought an RBI cap of 60% on NBFC loan-to-value. In what it calls the 2012-14 crisis, Manappuram's profit fell 83% from its peak and Muthoot's 42%.
What did the RBI change?
The RBI issued new gold loan directions in June 2025 and every lender had to comply by 1 April 2026. Three provisions matter here. Loan-to-value on a bullet loan is measured on the amount due at maturity, interest included. A bullet loan for consumption cannot run beyond twelve months. It can be renewed only after the accrued interest is paid. Banks have worked under a twelve-month limit and an interest-inclusive loan-to-value test on non-agricultural bullet loans since 2014. The directions put every lender, NBFCs included, under one rulebook.
The directions do not ban bullet loans. They do make a long bullet loan smaller. HDFC Securities' table shows that under the 85% ceiling that applies up to Rs 2.5 lakh, at an 18% interest rate, the most a lender can advance is 71% of the gold's value on a one-year bullet loan and 78% on a six-month one. It expected the rules to push lenders towards shorter tenors. From April, Muthoot, Manappuram and Bajaj Finance all launched shorter-tenor or periodic-interest schemes.
What happened next?
Muthoot's Stage 2 loans went from Rs 1,876 crore at the end of June to Rs 23,467 crore at the end of September. That is 1.1% of loan assets becoming 12.5% in one quarter. Stage 2 broadly covers loans 31 to 90 days overdue, and part of the increase reflects borrower- level classification, under which a customer's other loans move with the overdue one. Provisions and write-offs rose from an annualised 0.12% of average loan assets to 1.14%. Management attributes the rise to customers adjusting to monthly or periodic interest payments.
Manappuram's gold Stage 2 went from about 0.5% to about 5%. Its management attributed the rise to new shorter-tenor and EMI-based products. Monthly and quarterly schemes were 8 to 10% of its new disbursements. Bajaj Finance reported a Rs 1,047 crore rise in gold-loan Stage 2 from short-tenor schemes, which required the customer to pay interest and roll the loan over every three months. It stopped those schemes in August, and about Rs 550 crore had returned to Stage 1 by its results call.
Gold did not fall in that quarter. Muthoot's presentation values gold at Rs 12,942 a gram at the end of June and Rs 13,547 at the end of September. The falls came earlier and later. MCX gold futures touched Rs 1,80,779 per 10 grams on 29 January 2026 and closed at Rs 1,34,223 on 17 November 2026, about 26% lower. They traded near Rs 1.32 lakh on the morning of 18 November. CRIF's data for the June quarter, the first after the compliance deadline, shows new gold lending, excluding priority-sector gold loans, 25% below the March quarter and 47% above a year earlier. NBFCs' share of it by value fell from 38.0% to 27.8% and public sector banks' rose from 40.1% to 49.2%. CRIF says this may partly reflect the new loan-to-value norms.
Is this a habit problem or a capacity problem?
The managements attribute it to habit. Muthoot's managing director calls it a transitional phase. Manappuram's chief financial officer calls it largely behavioural. Bajaj Finance calls the movement transient. Muthoot's management also puts loan-to-value on its Stage 2 loans at about 72%, which means the gold is worth more than those loans.
On the evidence so far, I expect losses to stay low. Muthoot and Manappuram each report an average loan-to-value near 65% at the end of September. Crisil's stress tests in June 2026 found no loss of principal at portfolio level, though it said recovering accrued interest is harder.
My concern is about information, and it is separate from losses. A lender that first sees a borrower's repayment behaviour in month twelve has assessed the collateral but not the borrower's capacity to pay. The RBI now requires a repayment-capacity assessment above Rs 2.5 lakh. A monthly due date gives the lender that information every thirty days.
What we will do
Manappuram is moving customers from three- and six-month products to one-year loans. Its management said Stage 2 should probably normalise in the next couple of quarters, and also that the trend is hard to predict for a new product. Bajaj Finance is moving customers to twelve-month loans with optional monthly or quarterly interest payments. A one-year loan with no interim payment has one due date, so it produces repayment data once a year.
indiagold will continue with scheduled interest payments. A missed payment shows up within thirty days. On a twelve-month bullet loan the same problem shows up at maturity.